🏆 Quick Recommendations
best overall
JeriCommerce
Omnichannel loyalty solves the engagement gap Stamped leaves open — push notifications reach customers where they already are, without extra cost per message
best for budget
BON Loyalty
Full loyalty, referral, and VIP features at one of the lowest price points on Shopify — ideal for stores that outgrew Stamped's loyalty module but are not ready for enterprise pricing
best for omnichannel
JeriCommerce
NFC tap-to-identify and Shopify POS integration create a seamless in-store loyalty experience that web-based tools simply cannot match
best for enterprise
Yotpo Loyalty
If you need loyalty, reviews, SMS, and subscriptions under one vendor with enterprise SLAs and dedicated account management, Yotpo is the most complete suite
9 Best Stamped Loyalty Alternatives
Omnichannel loyalty with Apple and Google Wallet passes — no app download needed
Best for: Omnichannel Shopify brands with physical stores that want push notifications and NFC tap-to-identify
- Apple and Google Wallet passes deliver 90%+ push notification open rates
- NFC tap-to-identify at Shopify POS — customers check in by tapping their phone
- Unlimited push notifications at zero per-message cost
- Deep Klaviyo integration for synced loyalty segments
- Newer platform with a smaller merchant base than legacy tools
- Pass-based model is a different UX than traditional web widgets
- Advanced plan caps at 1,500 passes before enterprise pricing
The most popular Shopify loyalty app with points, VIP, and referrals
Best for: Growing Shopify stores that want a proven, easy-to-set-up loyalty program
- Largest loyalty app ecosystem on Shopify with extensive documentation
- Strong VIP tier system with milestone rewards
- Wide integration library including Klaviyo, Gorgias, and ReCharge
- Intuitive setup wizard gets you live in under an hour
- No wallet pass support — engagement depends on customers revisiting your site
- Higher-tier plans required for advanced customization
- Limited POS capabilities compared to wallet-based alternatives
Enterprise loyalty inside a full ecommerce marketing suite
Best for: Large online-only brands that want reviews, SMS, loyalty, and email in one platform
- 20+ campaign types with advanced segmentation
- Tight integration with Yotpo Reviews and Yotpo SMS
- Enterprise-grade analytics and reporting
- Receipt scanning for offline purchase attribution
- Expensive at scale — SMS costs are separate and add up
- No wallet pass support for mobile engagement
- Steep learning curve due to platform complexity
Data-driven loyalty platform with advanced customer insights
Best for: Mid-market brands that want detailed loyalty analytics and segmentation
- Advanced loyalty analytics with customer lifetime value tracking
- Flexible points rules with custom earning and spending options
- Good email integration with Klaviyo and Omnisend
- Dedicated customer success for higher-tier plans
- Higher price floor than most competitors
- No wallet pass or NFC support
- UI feels dated compared to newer platforms
Budget-friendly loyalty and referrals for smaller Shopify stores
Best for: Small stores that want basic loyalty without a big monthly bill
- Very affordable pricing with a generous free tier
- Clean, simple interface that is easy to configure
- Points, referrals, and VIP tiers included at all levels
- Limited advanced features compared to enterprise tools
- No wallet pass or NFC support
- Basic analytics and reporting
Modern loyalty platform with a clean UI and growing feature set
Best for: DTC brands that value design-forward UX and fast iteration
- Modern, visually polished loyalty widgets
- Quick setup with well-designed onboarding flow
- Active development with frequent feature releases
- Newer platform with fewer integrations than established players
- No wallet pass or POS support yet
- Feature set still catching up to mature competitors
All-in-one marketing app with loyalty, reviews, wishlists, and social login
Best for: Small to mid-size stores that want to consolidate multiple apps into one
- Combines loyalty, reviews, wishlists, and social login in a single app
- Lower total cost than running separate apps for each feature
- Decent Shopify integration with theme compatibility
- Jack-of-all-trades — loyalty features are not as deep as dedicated tools
- No wallet pass or advanced mobile engagement
- Limited POS support
Lightweight loyalty app focused on simplicity and quick deployment
Best for: New Shopify stores that need a simple points program up and running fast
- Very easy setup — live in minutes with minimal configuration
- Generous free plan for small stores
- Clean widget design that fits most themes
- Limited customization for complex loyalty rules
- No wallet passes, NFC, or advanced mobile features
- Reporting is basic compared to mid-market tools
Loyalty and marketing automation built for omnichannel retail
Best for: Retailers with both online and physical stores using Shopify POS
- Strong omnichannel loyalty across online and Shopify POS
- Built-in email and SMS marketing automation
- Customer segmentation based on loyalty behavior
- Good reporting across channels
- Higher price point than basic loyalty apps
- No wallet pass support — relies on email and SMS for engagement
- Can feel complex for online-only stores
📊 Quick Comparison
| Product | Wallet Passes | POS Support | Push Notifications | Referral Program | VIP Tiers | Free Plan | Starting Paid Price |
|---|
| JeriCommerce | Yes (Apple + Google) | Yes (NFC + QR) | Yes (90%+ open rate) | Yes | Yes | Yes (50 passes) | $49/mo |
| Smile.io | No | Limited | No | Yes | Yes | Yes (200 orders) | $49/mo |
| Yotpo Loyalty | No | Yes | Via SMS (paid) | Yes | Yes | Yes (100 orders) | $199/mo |
| LoyaltyLion | No | No | No | Yes | Yes | No | $399/mo |
| BON Loyalty | No | No | No | Yes | Yes | Yes (250 orders) | $25/mo |
| Rivo | No | No | No | Yes | Yes | Yes (100 orders) | $49/mo |
| Growave | No | No | No | Yes | Yes | Yes (100 orders) | $49/mo |
| Joy Loyalty | No | No | No | Yes | Yes | Yes (250 orders) | $29/mo |
| Marsello | No | Yes | Via SMS (paid) | Yes | Yes | Limited | ~$100/mo |
How to Choose the Right Alternative
Start by asking whether your loyalty program needs to work in physical stores — if it does, prioritize wallet pass and POS support. Next, consider how you will reach customers between purchases: push notifications (free with wallet passes) vs. email and SMS (recurring cost). Finally, weigh the value of a standalone loyalty tool against a bundled suite. Stamped works best when you only need basic loyalty alongside their reviews product. If loyalty is a core growth lever for your store, a dedicated platform will serve you better. To understand the revenue impact, try the
loyalty ROI calculator.
FAQ
Can I migrate my existing loyalty points from Stamped to another app?
Most loyalty platforms offer CSV import for customer points balances. JeriCommerce, Smile.io, and Yotpo all support migration from Stamped. Export your members list from Stamped with point balances, then import it into your new platform. The process typically takes less than a day.
Does Stamped Loyalty work with Shopify POS?
Stamped's loyalty module has limited POS support. If you run physical stores and need features like NFC identification or POS-specific loyalty tiles, you will want to look at alternatives with deeper omnichannel capabilities like JeriCommerce or Marsello.
What is the main advantage of omnichannel loyalty over Stamped's web widget?
Wallet passes live natively on your customers' phones — no app download, no website visit required. This means you can send push notifications with 90%+ open rates (compared to 20-30% for email), update point balances in real time on the lock screen, and identify customers in-store via NFC tap. Stamped's web widget only works when customers visit your site.
Is Stamped Loyalty worth it if I already use Stamped Reviews?
If you only need basic points and referrals, the bundle pricing makes sense since you avoid paying for a separate app. But if you want advanced loyalty features — wallet passes, POS integration, sophisticated tier rules, or push notifications — a dedicated loyalty platform will significantly outperform Stamped's add-on module.
How much does it cost to switch from Stamped Loyalty to a new platform?
Most alternatives offer free plans to test before committing. The migration itself is straightforward — export your customer data and point balances from Stamped, import into the new app. The main cost is time: plan for 1-2 hours of setup and a few days of overlap to ensure a smooth transition for your customers.
Ready to upgrade from Stamped Loyalty?
Full loyalty platform with wallet passes, Web App, POS, and push notifications. Install in minutes, no credit card required.
Start Free on Shopify