ComparisonMar 12, 2026

JeriCommerce vs Smile.io: Loyalty App Compared

JeriCommerce and Smile.io are two loyalty apps for Shopify that take different routes. Smile.io runs points, rewards and referrals through your store and customer accounts, with VIP tiers and the API on higher plans. JeriCommerce delivers loyalty as a card in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, with push notifications, Shopify POS tiles and Klaviyo and Shopify Flow integrations. This comparison uses prices from the Shopify App Store and each vendor's pricing page as of October 2026. Use the loyalty app cost comparison tool to run the numbers at your own order volume.

Quick Verdict

JeriCommerce wins on wallet-based loyalty: a card in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, push notifications on every plan, Shopify POS tiles and Klaviyo and Shopify Flow integrations. Smile.io wins on entry price, earning options and a much larger App Store track record.

Choose JeriCommerce if:

You want a loyalty card in the customer's wallet, push notifications on every plan, and Shopify POS tools for physical stores.

Choose Smile.io if:

You sell mostly online, want a $15/mo entry plan or the widest set of ways to earn and redeem, and prefer an app with thousands of reviews.

The Contenders

JeriCommerce

Wallet-based loyalty for Shopify, with POS tiles and Klaviyo and Shopify Flow integrations

Focus: Points, VIP tiers, referrals and rewards on an Apple Wallet and Google Wallet card, with push notifications, Shopify POS tiles, Klaviyo and Shopify Flow integrationsStarting at: Free plan (50 loyalty cards)

Smile.io

Loyalty, referrals, and VIP for ecommerce brands

Focus: Points, rewards and referrals for Shopify stores, with VIP tiers, points expiry and the API on higher plansStarting at: Free plan (200 orders/mo)

Head-to-Head Comparison

Loyalty Channel (How Customers Interact)criticalJeriCommerce wins

5vs3

JeriCommerceJeriCommerce puts the loyalty card in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, so customers do not need to download an app. You set the logo, colors and balance label, choose a QR code, barcode or NFC identifier, and can use a different card design per tier.

Smile.ioSmile.io runs points, rewards and referrals through your Shopify store, checkout and customer accounts. The plans we checked list no wallet card, so customers interact when they visit your store.

Push Notifications & Customer CommunicationcriticalJeriCommerce wins

5vs2

JeriCommerceJeriCommerce sends push notifications to the wallet pass on every plan, including Free. Automatic ones fire on balance change, tier change, reward unlocked and referral completed. You can also schedule notifications or trigger them from Shopify Flow or Klaviyo, and location notifications can fire near your stores (GPS on both wallets, iBeacon on Apple only).

Smile.ioSmile.io lists nudges from the Essential plan ($15/mo) and a Klaviyo integration for email. The plans we checked list no wallet push notifications.

Physical Store / POS IntegrationimportantJeriCommerce wins

5vs3

JeriCommerceJeriCommerce adds Shopify POS tiles: staff scan the card QR with a camera or scanner, add or remove points, redeem rewards, and look customers up by email or phone. A receipt QR lets customers enrol in store. NFC identification is available on the Advanced and Enterprise plans only.

Smile.ioSmile.io's pricing page lists Shopify POS support from the Standard plan ($79/mo). Its Shopify App Store listing places POS compatibility on the Free plan, so confirm before you buy.

Points & Earning RulescriticalSmile.io wins

4vs5

JeriCommerceCustomers earn points for purchases (a percentage of the order), account verification, profile completion, social follows (up to 4 networks), installing the card and store check-ins. Five custom earning flows can be built with Shopify Flow or the API, and Shopify Flow offers 18 triggers and 8 actions. Rewards include fixed rewards, points as cash, Shopify discount types (fixed, percentage, free shipping, buy X get Y) and on-demand codes.

Smile.ioSmile.io lists 15+ ways to earn and redeem on the Free plan, bonus events from Standard ($79/mo) and points expiry from Growth ($199/mo). It offers more earning and redemption options than JeriCommerce.

Referral ProgramimportantTie

4vs4

JeriCommerceBuilt-in referral program: the QR code on the loyalty card doubles as the referral link.

Smile.ioReferrals are included from the Free plan, alongside points and rewards.

VIP TiersimportantTie

5vs5

JeriCommerceVIP tiers based on points thresholds, recalculated by calendar year, anniversary or lifetime, with a different card design per tier and an automatic push notification on tier change.

Smile.ioVIP tiers are part of the Growth plan ($199/mo) and above on Smile.io's pricing page, so smaller plans do not include them.

Klaviyo / Email Marketing IntegrationimportantJeriCommerce wins

5vs4

JeriCommerceKlaviyo integration with events, segments and custom fields. JeriCommerce also works as a loyalty provider in Klaviyo Customer Hub and is listed in the Klaviyo marketplace.

Smile.ioSmile.io includes one integration (Klaviyo) on Essential ($15/mo), two on Standard and unlimited integrations on Growth ($199/mo), plus the API.

Pricing & ValuecriticalTie

4vs4

JeriCommerceFree $0 (50 loyalty cards, 200 transactions, 2 rewards), Growth $49/mo (1,000 cards, 750 transactions, 5 rewards), Advanced $149/mo (1,500 cards, 4,000 transactions, unlimited rewards) and a custom Enterprise plan. Limits count loyalty cards and transactions, not total store customers.

Smile.ioFree $0 (200 orders/mo), Essential $15/mo (500 orders), Standard $79/mo (1,000 orders), Growth $199/mo (2,500 orders, $20 per extra 100), Plus $999/mo billed annually (7,500 orders) and custom Enterprise. Smile.io is cheaper at the low end; the two price on different units, so compare at your own volume.

Setup & App Store Track Recordnice-to-haveSmile.io wins

4vs5

JeriCommerceJeriCommerce installs in about 5 minutes and requires a Shopify Basic plan or higher. Its Shopify App Store listing shows a 5.0 rating from 10 reviews, so the track record is short.

Smile.ioSmile.io has a 4.9 rating from 4,629 reviews on the Shopify App Store, a much larger base of merchant feedback than JeriCommerce has.

Pricing Comparison

JeriCommerce

Free$0/mo

50 loyalty cards · 200 transactions · 2 rewards · Push notifications · 3rd-party integrations & API

Growth$49/mo

1,000 loyalty cards · 750 transactions · 5 rewards · All earning flows · All integrations

Advanced$149/mo

1,500 loyalty cards · 4,000 transactions · Unlimited rewards · All features & integrations · NFC identification

EnterpriseCustom

Custom limits · NFC identification

Smile.io

Free$0/mo

200 orders/mo · Points, rewards, referrals · 15+ ways to earn and redeem

Essential$15/mo

500 orders/mo · 1 integration (Klaviyo) · Nudges · Analytics

Standard$79/mo

1,000 orders/mo · Free product rewards · Shopify POS support · 2 integrations · Bonus events

Growth$199/mo

2,500 orders/mo ($20 per extra 100) · VIP tiers · Points expiry · Unlimited integrations & API · 25+ reports

Plus$999/mo billed annually

7,500 orders/mo · Custom API rate limits · Priority support

EnterpriseContact sales

Unlimited orders

Prices as of October 2026, from the Shopify App Store and each vendor's pricing page. Smile.io is cheaper at the low end (Essential at $15/mo), and its Free plan allows 200 orders a month. The two apps meter different things, so compare them at your own volume: JeriCommerce counts loyalty cards and transactions, Smile.io counts orders. Smile.io puts VIP tiers on its $199/mo Growth plan, and JeriCommerce lists push notifications on every plan. To estimate the ROI either app can deliver, try the loyalty program ROI calculator.

Final Verdict

JeriCommerce

Smile.io

JeriCommerce wins on wallet-based engagement, push notifications and Shopify POS tools. Smile.io wins on earning options, entry price and App Store track record. Your choice depends on whether you want a wallet card as your loyalty channel (JeriCommerce) or a widely used program running through your online store (Smile.io). For practical program ideas once you have chosen your platform, browse our loyalty program ideas for fashion or loyalty ideas for food and beverage brands.

Choose JeriCommerce if:

You have physical stores or plan to open them. You want a loyalty card in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet with push notifications on every plan, Shopify POS tiles, and optionally NFC identification on the Advanced plan.

Choose Smile.io if:

You sell mostly online, want a low-cost entry plan ($15/mo) or a larger set of ways to earn and redeem points, and value an app with thousands of Shopify App Store reviews.

FAQ

How do the free plans compare?

Smile.io's Free plan covers 200 orders a month with points, rewards, referrals and 15+ ways to earn and redeem. JeriCommerce's Free plan covers 50 loyalty cards and 200 transactions with 2 rewards, push notifications and 3rd-party integrations and API. Growth on JeriCommerce ($49/mo) raises this to 1,000 cards, 750 transactions and 5 rewards.

Which is better for Shopify POS?

JeriCommerce offers Shopify POS tiles to scan the card QR, add or remove points and redeem rewards, with lookup by email or phone and NFC identification on Advanced and Enterprise. Smile.io's pricing page lists Shopify POS support from the Standard plan ($79/mo), while its Shopify App Store listing places it on Free, so check which applies to you.

Do customers need to download an app for either?

No. Smile.io works through your store and customer accounts. JeriCommerce uses Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, so the loyalty card sits in the phone's wallet with no separate app.

Which has more reviews on the Shopify App Store?

Smile.io shows a 4.9 rating from 4,629 reviews. JeriCommerce shows a 5.0 rating from 10 reviews. The ratings are both high, but Smile.io's is based on far more merchants.

What does Smile.io cost as order volume grows?

Prices as of October 2026: Standard is $79/mo for 1,000 orders, Growth is $199/mo for 2,500 orders with $20 per extra 100, and Plus is $999/mo billed annually for 7,500 orders. JeriCommerce charges extra for cards and transactions above plan limits, which you can see in its Shopify App Store listing.

Does Smile.io work with Klaviyo?

Yes. Smile.io includes one integration (Klaviyo) from the Essential plan and unlimited integrations on Growth. JeriCommerce also integrates with Klaviyo (events, segments, custom fields, Customer Hub) and Shopify Flow.

Try JeriCommerce Free: Wallet Loyalty on Shopify

Loyalty cards in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, Shopify POS tiles and push notifications. Start on the free plan from the Shopify App Store.

Install Free on Shopify

5.0 ★ Shopify App Store · 200+ brands · Free plan available